Naughty // Nice
Naughty // Nice is a Rare Sorcery // Sorcery from Happy Holidays (12) in Magic: The Gathering. Mana cost {1}{B}{B} // {1}{W}{W}. Color identity: B, W. Cactaur's latest catalog snapshot shows a market reference near $58.49 for ungraded copies.
Market
on eBayNo live listings right now.
Browse on eBayListings could not be loaded.
Some links may earn Cactaur a commission when you purchase on eBay.
Who is this card for?
Naughty // Nice suits collectors and players working on Happy Holidays who need the Rare slot. Treat $58.49 as a starting reference only — verify finish, border treatment, and condition before paying premium singles prices.
What is Naughty // Nice from Happy Holidays?
Naughty // Nice is a Sorcery // Sorcery in Happy Holidays numbered 12. Mana cost {1}{B}{B} // {1}{W}{W}. Color identity: B, W. Naughty // Nice (12) is a chase-tier Rare Sorcery // Sorcery in Happy Holidays. Finish, border treatment, and grade drive most of the premium beyond raw near-mint quotes.
What is Naughty // Nice worth today?
Cactaur tracks a market reference near $58.49 for Naughty // Nice. Low and high spread runs $58.49 to null. This printing is from Happy Holidays. Collector number 12 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets. Catalogued rarity: Rare. The set released in 2012.
| Set | Happy Holidays |
|---|---|
| Number | 12 |
| Rarity | Rare |
| TCGPlayer USD | $58.49 |
| Cardmarket EUR | — |
| foil | $58.49 |
Card stats
| Colors | B, W |
|---|
How collectible is Naughty // Nice?
Naughty // Nice is a Rare printing in Happy Holidays. Chase-tier slots combine scarcity, art, and format demand — prices move with reprint news and tournament results. This printing is from Happy Holidays. Collector number 12 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets.
What are the key details for Naughty // Nice?
Naughty // Nice lists as Sorcery // Sorcery. Artist: Greg Staples. Rules text is indexed in the catalog for search and deck research. This printing is from Happy Holidays. Collector number 12 distinguishes this printing from same-name cards in other sets. Catalogued rarity: Rare.
Cactaur's take
Naughty // Nice (12) is a chase-tier Rare Sorcery // Sorcery in Happy Holidays. Finish, border treatment, and grade drive most of the premium beyond raw near-mint quotes.
Pros
- Naughty // Nice is catalogued as Rare Sorcery // Sorcery in Happy Holidays, making set and collector number verification straightforward.
- Public market data shows a reference near $58.49.
- Mana cost {1}{B}{B} // {1}{W}{W} and type line Sorcery // Sorcery help deck builders confirm the correct printing quickly.
Cons
- Raw market prices vary by condition and finish — near-mint estimates are not slab grades.
Verdict: Use $58.49 as a benchmark, then adjust for finish, grade, and how quickly you need to buy or sell.
FAQ
What is Naughty // Nice from Happy Holidays?
Naughty // Nice is a Rare Sorcery // Sorcery from Happy Holidays numbered 12 in Magic: The Gathering. Cactaur indexes set, rarity, mana cost, and market references for this printing.
How much is Naughty // Nice worth?
Cactaur's catalog snapshot shows a market reference near $58.49 for ungraded Naughty // Nice. Condition, finish, and recent sold comps can move realized prices above or below that benchmark.
What rarity is Naughty // Nice?
Naughty // Nice is catalogued as Rare in Happy Holidays. Use the collector number and set symbol on listings to confirm you are buying this exact printing.
How do I verify the correct Naughty // Nice printing?
Match set code hho, collector number 12, and finish treatment. Scryfall-backed metadata on this page is the reference Cactaur uses for catalog keys. This printing is from Happy Holidays.
Why does Naughty // Nice trade at a premium?
Naughty // Nice combines Rare scarcity with art, finish, and format demand. Chase slots often move on reprint rumors, tournament results, and condition-sensitive buyer interest.
Related cards
- Snow Mercy — Happy Holidays
- Yule Ooze — Happy Holidays
- Stocking Tiger — Happy Holidays
- Stocking Tiger — Happy Holidays
- Mishra's Toy Workshop — Happy Holidays
- Goblin Sleigh Ride — Happy Holidays